JimDoty.org

Home
Gallery
Nature
Travel
Learn
Tips
Digital
Links
About

E-mail

Search

Prints for Purchase

Support This Site

My Photo Blog
 

This site in:
English 
Espanol  
Francais 
Deutsch  
Italiano
PortuguÍs

Canon 10D vs 20D

Canon 10D vs 20D
by Jim Doty, Jr.

With each new generation, digital cameras just keep getting better.  In their line of intermediate level digital SLRs, Canon has introduced the D30 ($3300), the D60 ($2200), the 10D ($1500), and now the 20D ($1450). Each is an improvement over the previous model.  The same could be said for Nikon and other camera makers - cameras get better and prices usually drop.

The Canon 20D is a step forward from the 10D, but in many areas this is just an incremental step. 

First of all, the biggest non-change. The 20D has the same 1.6X field of view crop as the 10D and Digital Rebel. Due to an image sensor that is smaller than 35mm film, all images are cropped. This means the effective focal length of a lens is 60% longer than when the same lens is used on a 35mm film camera. For example, a 100mm lens on a 20D has the same field of view as a 160mm lens on a 35mm film camera. This is great for long lens work, but not good for wide angle work.

Here are some of the differences, both great and small. I have highlighted the significant (in my opinion) improvements on the 20D and one disadvantage.

10D:  6 megapixel sensor
20D:  8 megapixel sensor

10D:  2.5 second start up time
20D:  0.2 second start up time

10D:  3.3 frames per second, 9 frame buffer
20D:  5 frames per second, 23 frame buffer

10D:  1/4000 top shutter speed
20D:  1/8000 top shutter speed

10D:  1/200 X sync
20D:  1/250 X sync

10D:  5 point autofocus system
20D:  9 point autofocus system

The autofocus system on the 20D is faster and more accurate than on the 10D and works in lower light.

The built in pop-up flash is higher than on the 20D so it clears more lenses and hoods (less chance of dark partial circles at the bottom of the frame). It also means less red eye.

The 20D is smaller and lighter.

The 10D and 20D have essentially the same noise levels from ISO 100-400 but the 20D has less digital noise at ISO 800 and higher.

The 20D has USB 2.0 for faster downloads to a computer.

The 20D has a black and white mode to emulate typical black and white filters used with film cameras.

The 20D has true RAW + jpeg support. It can write two separate files to the flash card, one in RAW and one in jpeg. You can read the jpeg version of a photo without special software. The 10D embeds the jpeg in the raw file data so you need special software to extract he jpeg file.

The 20D has a two axis white balance menu option, blue - amber, and magenta - green.

The 20D takes the new EF-S lenses.

The 20D has a louder shutter than the 10D, a disadvantage.

So what changes matter? That will depend on what you shoot and how.  Here is how it stacks up for me.

The 2 megapixel gain in sensor size is not a big change. If you work at lower ISOs, the image quality between the 10D and 20D is going to be essentially the same. The 10D can already provide 12x18 inch and larger prints with excellent quality. If you do a lot of low light work without flash, the lower noise levels in the 20D at 800 and 1600 could be  important. The 20D will allow some cropping and still have an image file as big as one from an uncropped file from the 10D.

Waiting for the 10D to turn on (or wake up) when a fleeting shot appears can be frustrating. The virtually instant response of the 20D is a big difference.  If you take your time and shoot mainly landscapes and other subjects that don't change or run away, this is no big deal.

If you do action photography, the faster autofocus is a big asset. Shooting 5 frames per second is not a big deal for me, but having a 23 frame buffer is a big deal for fast and furious sports and wildlife action.

I use the built in flash a lot for snapshots. The higher pop-up flash height is a big advantage in reducing red eye and avoiding dark areas at the bottom of the frame.

If you love wide angle work, being able to use the Canon EF-S 10-22mm lens on your 20D (or Digital Rebel) is a big advantage. On the 20D the field of view of the 10-22mm lens is the same as a using a 16-32mm lens on a 35mm camera body.  This is the first lens that allows true wide angle work with a digital camera body with a 1.6X field of view crop. The EF-S lenses won't work on Canon film bodies (even if the lens is modified). You can use the EF-S 10-22mm lens on a 10D body if you cut off part of the back of the EF-S lens mount. I don't recommend this but a search on the internet will tell you how to do this and the risks involved.

Should you buy this camera?  That all depends. If the $1450 price tag is not an issue, then here are some considerations.

If you are shooting film now and are thinking about jumping to digital and you have Canon EF lenses already, this camera makes the jump to digital very worthwhile. I bought a 10D a year and a half ago and it was a great decision.  (See my 10D reviews elsewhere at this site.)  Getting a 20D now for about the same price as a 10D cost 18 months ago makes a lot of sense.  If you want to save $300 and the 20D advantages aren't important to you, get a 10D. It is still a great camera.

If you have a 10D now, you will have to look above at the improvements in the 20D and see if they matter in your shooting. I don't see much advantage in upgrading for landscape photographers, and I see more reason to upgrade for sports and action photographers. For low light users, it is a mixed bag. The lower noise levels are offset in part by the louder shutter. I do low light level work at church services and a louder shutter is a big disadvantage.

If you have bunch of Nikon lenses and you are happy with them, it would make sense to get a Nikon D70 if you want to jump to digital. It is a better camera than the Canon Digital Rebel and marginally better than the Canon 10D (except perhaps for astrophotography, see the link below). The Canon 20D has an image quality edge over the D70, but Nikon will come out with an improved model, then Canon will, and so on. The competition is good for all of us.

This applies to other brands of cameras also.  GOOD LENSES ARE FOREVER (more or less), DIGITAL BODIES ARE TEMPORARY. If you have a good collection of lenses that you like, find a digital body that will work with your current lenses. If your lenses are orphaned without a good digital body to use them on, then a Canon 20D and some Canon EF or EF-S lenses would serve you well

Buy a Canon 20D body or a Canon 20D body with EF-S 18-55mm lens at Amazon.com

Buy a Canon 10D at Amazon.com

Buy a Canon 20D, 10D, or almost anything else photographic at Adorama, one of the biggest, best, and most reliable photo dealers on the internet.

Two of the best detailed reviews of the Canon 20D are at DP Review and the Luminous Landscape. A comparison of the Canon 10D vs 20D as well as of the Canon 10D vs Nikon D70 (in French and English) for astrophotography is online at astrosurf.com.


November 15, 2004
Updated December 9, 2004

 

[Home] [Gallery] [Nature] [Travel] [Learn] [Tips] [Digital] [Links] [About]

Shop at Adorama - one of the best, largest, and most reliable camera dealers on the internet.

This site and all of its contents are copyrighted. Reproduction in any form is a violation of US and international  copyright laws.